Libecht
Well-Known Member
I consider myself very logical and quite reasonable, and I often have problem communicating (or arguing) with NTs.
Before anyone tells me the cliche, no I'm the "He has different opinions so I'm right and he's unreasonable" kind of people. By "logical" I meant the actual logic, the one which includes 'premises' 'conclusions' and 'If q then p if not p then not q".
The kind of argument that often occurs between me and an NT:
"If the purpose of your question was to seek truth, then you asked the wrong one because both answers lead to the same conclusion."
"But if what you just said was true, than your previous assumption couldn't possibly be true as well. Yes I know what you wanted to do but I'm telling you it's pointless!"
"If you could keep asking 'Why?' it'd create an infinite causality chain.......NO I just told you it would be infinite"
In these situations NTs usually keep holding their arguments without realizing their logical flaws, leaving me with a headache.
Do you have similar experiences? Is it my fault or Aspies are really better at logic and reasoning?
Before anyone tells me the cliche, no I'm the "He has different opinions so I'm right and he's unreasonable" kind of people. By "logical" I meant the actual logic, the one which includes 'premises' 'conclusions' and 'If q then p if not p then not q".
The kind of argument that often occurs between me and an NT:
"If the purpose of your question was to seek truth, then you asked the wrong one because both answers lead to the same conclusion."
"But if what you just said was true, than your previous assumption couldn't possibly be true as well. Yes I know what you wanted to do but I'm telling you it's pointless!"
"If you could keep asking 'Why?' it'd create an infinite causality chain.......NO I just told you it would be infinite"
In these situations NTs usually keep holding their arguments without realizing their logical flaws, leaving me with a headache.
Do you have similar experiences? Is it my fault or Aspies are really better at logic and reasoning?
Last edited: